basforge

Search titles, text and the “If it doesn’t work” cases.

    RU

    What spoils a layout: the sign, why it hurts, what to use instead

    A page is more often spoiled by excess: everything highlighted, uniform spacing, gray paler than the threshold, a line across the whole monitor. By group: what the mistake looks like, why it gets in the way of reading, and what to put in its place.

    Text

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    a wall of text: a 10+ line paragraph when scanning, the eye takes the first line and moves on a paragraph is one thought, 3–5 lines (Chunking text)
    a line across the whole monitor, 120–150 characters the eye loses the start of the next line and rereads a 45–80 character column (Line length)
    justified text without hyphenation the browser stretches the spaces, and white “rivers” run through the text left-aligned (Left-aligned)
    long centered text every line has its own start — the eye looks for it again each time center 1–2 lines: a heading, a caption
    paragraphs IN CAPS the letters share one height and lose ascenders and descenders, so words lose their shape; all caps reads slower than lowercase — Tinker and Paterson measured it back in 1928 caps for short labels of 1–2 words, with letter spacing
    a thin weight (font-weight: 300 and below) in body text on an ordinary non-Retina screen the strokes turn gray and contrast drops 400 for text, thin only for a large heading
    three or more typefaces each typeface is its own voice; the page sounds like an anthology one for text and headings, a second monospace one for code
    long passages in italic italic is for a word or two; in many fonts italic in other scripts switches to handwritten forms — Cyrillic “т” looks like “m”, “и” like “u” — and long passages get harder to read italic for a word or two; longer emphasis another way

    Emphasis

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    half a paragraph in bold emphasis works only against ordinary text one or two spots per screen (Bold: one or two spots)
    underlining that isn’t a link on screen, underlined means a link; people click it bold; keep underlining for links
    bold, color, caps and an exclamation mark at once four signals where one is enough one method
    “Important!”, “Note!” every other paragraph warnings lose weight and start getting skipped one warning per page
    emoji as list bullets a screen reader reads each one aloud (“green check mark”), and the item starts with a picture instead of a word an ordinary bullet; an icon only if it means something

    Color and contrast

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    gray text lighter than #767676 on white below 4.5:1 it fails WCAG and vanishes in sunlight secondary text at 4.5:1 or more (Text contrast)
    color as the only signal: “red ones are errors” about 8% of men distinguish red and green less well; printed in black and white the meaning is lost color plus a second signal: an icon, a word, a shape
    five or more accent colors color stops meaning anything: every block has its own one accent plus neutrals; colors for meaningful labels (formats, statuses)
    white text on a light button on green #22c55e it’s 2.28:1 a darker background or dark text
    a dark theme that inverts the light one shadows, grays and images are designed for a light background; inverted, everything is flat and garish dark theme colors of its own, with contrast checked separately
    a pure #000 background and pure #fff text 21:1 is 4.7 times the threshold; bright white on black glares in the dark near-black and near-white: #131210 and #f2eee8 — 16.2:1

    Spacing and alignment

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    the same spacing everywhere you can’t see what belongs with what: a heading hangs between paragraphs smaller inside a group, larger between groups (White space in CSS)
    identical blocks with different spacing the eye sees the difference and looks for meaning in it a spacing scale: 4, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32 px
    elements on different vertical lines the edge “jitters” — the page looks sloppy even if you can’t say why a shared grid: everything side by side starts from one line
    a border around every block borders draw a grid, and attention goes to it group with spacing or a background; a border only where nothing else works
    no margins at the screen edge on a phone text sticks to the edge, and the first letter disappears under the rounded corner a margin of 16 px or more

    Tables and lists

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    a grid of lines around every cell the lines are louder than the data thin horizontal rules, or alternating row backgrounds
    left-aligned numbers the digits don’t line up by place, so comparing is hard numbers right-aligned, with tabular figures: font-variant-numeric: tabular-nums
    a one-column table that’s a list a bulleted list
    6+ columns on a phone horizontal scrolling, and the header scrolls away 2–3 columns, or cards on a narrow screen
    a list nested 4 levels deep the links between levels get lost 2 levels; deeper — a subheading and a new list

    Images, icons, screenshots

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    a screenshot of code or a terminal can’t be copied, searched or read on a phone a code block as text (Code as text)
    a screenshot of the whole screen the button you need is a dot somewhere in the corner crop to the right spot and mark where to look
    icons without labels only the most familiar icons are understood unambiguously: search, close, home an icon with a label next to it
    decorative images in every section meaningful images can’t be told from decoration, so both get skipped an image where it explains; one decorative image for the whole page
    a stock photo of “a team at a laptop” it carries no information but takes up the first screen a diagram, a screenshot, a relevant illustration — or nothing

    The page and the interface

    Sign Why it hurts What to use instead
    the first screen holds a banner, cookies, a chat and a newsletter signup the answer is pushed to the second screen, while 57% of the time is spent on the first the first screen holds the heading, the lead and one action (One screen, one idea)
    a slide carousel the text moves on before it’s read; Erik Runyon’s measurements (2013) on the University of Notre Dame site found about 1% of visitors click a carousel, and 84% of clicks go to the first slide one main message, static; the rest as a list below
    a placeholder instead of a field label it vanishes on input: you can no longer see what was asked a label above the field, and the placeholder as an example value
    links reading “here”, “more”, “read more” a list of links doesn’t say where they lead link text says where it leads (Link text)
    buttons smaller than 24×24 px fingers miss them, especially at the screen edge 24×24 px or more (WCAG 2.5.8), 44×44 for frequent ones (2.5.5)

    If it doesn’t work

    The page looks “cheap”, and it’s unclear what exactly is wrong

    Cause
    Most often small things that add up: three typefaces, five shades of gray, different spacing on identical blocks, alignment to different lines.
    Fix
    Squint at the page or blur it (Checking presentation): the eye itself shows where blobs and lines don’t match.

    Everything follows the rules, and the page is boring

    Cause
    The rules remove what’s in the way but give no accent: everything is even, and the eye has nothing to catch on first.
    Fix
    One strong accent per screen: a large heading, an illustration, a number — whatever is primary (Three levels of importance).